Re: A post occasioned by a viewing of The Illusionist

1

It's rumored that forms of communication exist by which your questions might be answered and yet no one would be in danger of viewing spoilers. Information theory specialists still speculate as to what those forms might be though, so for now I'll have to risk reading future spoilers.

horizontal rule
2

Are you trying to tell us you think your mom is a lesbian, or that she's sexist? Or both?

horizontal rule
3

I'm just sayin' what I'm sayin'.

horizontal rule
4

I haven't seen the movie yet - it looks both thin and dull. I couldn't believe they could wrench a full-length movie out of such a concise short story. Read that, if you can. It's very satisfying (but again - a full length movie? How?). Incidentally, it was in a recent issue of All-Story (by Zoetrope - F.F. Coppola's outfit), a surprisingly great short story magazine.

Oh, and Jessica Biel actually turns out to be a dude.

horizontal rule
5

Named Rosebud.

horizontal rule
6

The horror.

horizontal rule
7

Speaking of ass.

horizontal rule
8

2: I think you're reading too much into it.

horizontal rule
9

And yet, I add joy to the world.

horizontal rule
10

You're no Kantian.

horizontal rule
11

It would be great if Ben's mum were bi, then even more of us could sleep with her. Of course, if she's sexist, I'm not going anywhere near her.

horizontal rule
12

I freely admit that I don't get 10.

horizontal rule
13

Has anyone (besides Wolfson, for whom I know the answer to part a)) seen The Illusionist, Half Nelson, This Film Is Not Yet Rated, or ? If you've seen one of them, did you like it? If you've seen more than one, how would you compare them? Without subsequent information, which might include being told that my filmgoing companion has already seen one or more of these, I'm going to see Half Nelson.

horizontal rule
14

That last movie, after This Film Is Not Yet Rated, sounds intriguing. I have seen none of those but can tell you that Becks and a friend saw Half Nelson. There was a post about it.

horizontal rule
15

my mom commented on Biel's ass

Yes, but what did she say? Did she approve?

This will help us decide if she is sexist, gay, a person of sound judgment, etc.

horizontal rule
16

I have seen The Illusionist. I'm a big fan of Steven Millhauser, but I hadn't read the short story.

I have no problems with following the plot of the movie. I think it's fair to complain that some of the illusions couldn't possibly have been done with the technology of the time, but that's no biggie. I have some minor quibbles with the timetable of the blowoff. But by and large I thought the film was well-directed and -acted, and the cinematography excellent. I frankly didn't pay much attention to Biel's lips.

I'm looking forward to The Prestige, and I have read the Christopher Priest novel.

It does seem that you can't do a film about magic without involving Ricky Jay.

horizontal rule
17

I assume I did something wrong with my italics tags, the last one was meant to be Mutual Appreciation.

horizontal rule
18

Hey, I thought of Brooks Hansen, too.

Of those three moives I've only seen The Illusionist. Liked it a lot. When I left the theater I was thinking, okay, that was diverting enough. But it has been one of those that I like better the more I think about it. And it is very pretty — the colors, the focus — though there were a couple of gratuitously arty shots.

But Ben, did you really not get it? Other than the doctor/guy at the train identity, I think I had figured most of it out before the end.

horizontal rule
19

I think it's fair to complain that some of the illusions couldn't possibly have been done with the technology of the time

This doesn't seem like it would be a sensical complaint about the story.

horizontal rule
20

18: I missed the doctor/guy at the train too, but that's hardly surprising. I'd put most of it together fairly early, and was certain when the prince and inspector were talking, so I thought it was fairly obvious. I know the person I was with was surprised though...

Agree it had pretty moments. It was ok, as you say, a reasonable diversion. Some of the CGI etc. in the illusions was jarring though --- I would have preferred more realistically fake, if that makes sense.

horizontal rule
21

But Ben, did you really not get it? Other than the doctor/guy at the train identity, I think I had figured most of it out before the end.

What I didn't get was the precise mechanics—what was going to happen I had figured out, but exactly how it happened remained a bit opaque. This has since been cleared up.

horizontal rule
22

To a certain extent. I'm not a canny audience.

horizontal rule
23

The reviewers at The Onion were not enthusiatic about the ratings documentary.

horizontal rule
24

Half Nelson is a good film for people who don't mind inaction. Nothing much happens.

horizontal rule
25

She's his sister and his daughter.

horizontal rule