Re: And The Tree Was Happy--But Not Really

1

My theory is that Silverstein woke up one day and said "How come there aren't any children's books that make you feel like shit? I'll think I'll write one!"

horizontal rule
2

yeah, but it's not like Hans Christian Andersen is a laff riot. my fave: the girl who trod on a loaf. but the giving tree, that shit is just wrong. and mimes make it worse.

horizontal rule
3

Mime + The Giving Tree: two great tastes that taste great together!

Funny coincidence: I was just thinking about SS's "Ickle Me, Pickle Me, Tickle Me Too" in the context of a LanguageHat post which mentions Eugene Field's "Wynken, Blynken and Nod".

horizontal rule
4

like all good children's literature, it's about death.

horizontal rule
5

I need to search the archives for it, but I've said here previously that you're absolutely right -- it's a sick, screwed up book.

horizontal rule
6

1 seems entirely plausible.

horizontal rule
7

Essay assignment: compare and contrast The Giving Tree and Oscar Wilde's "The Happy Prince."

horizontal rule
8

The Giving Tree came up recently on this thread.

LB came out against The Giving Tree here.

As I said here I am convinced Silverstein wrote a fucked up book on purpose, but what that purpose is, I don't know.

horizontal rule
9

"I abominate The Giving Tree"?

Anyway, I think you're right about it being a metaphor for never-failing abundant (self-sacrificial) love, whether of God or just those trying to emulate him.

I don't understand all the hate on this book -- I remember thinking it was nice/touching as a kid. I haven't read it in 20+ years, so maybe I'm forgetting something (though the plot is pretty simple, IIRC).

horizontal rule
10

Oops... the dictionary tells me abominate turns out not to mean what I thought it meant, so I retract the query that begins 9.

horizontal rule
11

??? Abominate means "loathe", which meaning is perfectly consistent with my reading of 9. What did you think it meant?

horizontal rule
12

As a child, there were two stories that made me cry. The Fox & the Hound, and The Giving Tree.

To this day I love them both dearly.

But mimes are freaky, and I can't imagine how one would mime The Giving Tree.

horizontal rule
13

Well, here's the thing -- it's a fucking tree. It can't assert itself. Yet it's so self-righteous about how giving it is. That's what I hate.

horizontal rule
14

Yeah the subtext of that book (as I remember it) is that the tree is laying a guilt trip on the man, is why he can't ever really feel at peace til he has used up the tree and himself. Yes, sexist.

horizontal rule
15

1: I've never read The Giving Tree, but The Last Battle made me feel like shit when I read it as a child.

horizontal rule
16

1: Somebody gave us a pretty non-descript Disney book when Keegan was a baby that was meant to teach shapes. Baby Mickey has lost his ball and his friends are helping him look for it. Baby Goofy brings a boat, but that not it, the boat is a triangle, etc. Goes through all the shapes until they find the ball and everybody's happy and the friends go home.

Keegan would bring that book to be read to him frequently and every single time would burst into tears at the end of it because all of Baby Mickey's friends had gone away and now he was alone.

horizontal rule
17

There was a book called 'Lentil' that terrified me as a child because a character sucked on a lemon and his lips puckered.

horizontal rule
18

15: Which part? Lewis depiction of all those nasty working-class atheists spending eternity in locked in a midden of their own minds, the train wreck that lets everyone (except Susan) go to Heaven tra-la-la, or the problem of Susan itself?

House of Stairs gave me nightmares, but that's a book for a slightly older audience.

horizontal rule
19

Shel Silverstein was a songwriter too who wrote mostly country songs, including "A Boy Named Sue". He was the brains behind "Dr. Hook". He lived in the Playboy mansion and did a lot of writing for Playboy, starting in 1956. Seems to have been a very odd fish.

horizontal rule
20

18: The train wreck. Everybody died!

That upset me so much I actually removed The Last Battle from the Narnia box set on my bookshelf, and hid it away in a drawer where I wouldn't see it.

horizontal rule
21

No book upset me until I read The Trial as a teenager. Just to speed things up, I plan on reading it to my children as early as possible.

horizontal rule
22

20: Hey, Zadfrack -- you're Battlepanda Brock? Or am I all confused?

horizontal rule
23

I thought the point of The Giving Tree was so we'd think, "That kid is one twisted fucker. Poor tree, I need to grow up to be a conservationist."

No?

horizontal rule
24

22: Yes.

horizontal rule
25

23: I got something like that, too. The "you should hate and dismember your mother" message is completely new to me.

horizontal rule
26

25: Though not, of course, a new message altogether.

horizontal rule
27

yeah, I've always thought Silverstein was a sick, sick fuck for writing that book.

I remember a friend of mine telling me that she dumped a boyfriend early on because he gave her a copy of it. Good move; if his views on romance are based on that book, better to get shut of him right now.

horizontal rule
28

and Alameida

I don't want to go all grumpy and complaining on you, but.

A pen? You were going to throw a pen at this guy's head?

Could you make sure, the next time you go to a mime performance, that your pockets contain something with a little more heft, a little more mass?

I mean, I'd a took and bounced a rock off his head. Which is why I always keep a good rock in my pocket.

At the very least, bring a sword. Cause I don't know about mighty and shit, but the sword is definitely heavier than the pen.

(All is forgiven if it was a poison pen, with tip unbated).

horizontal rule
29

I guess I didn't really think far enough ahead on that one. chance favors the prepared mime.

horizontal rule
30

Coincidentally, I just re-read The Giving Tree about a week ago in the waiting area of a local barbershop while waiting for a haircut. The tree doesn't try to guilt trip the boy, she just keeps on giving and giving until finally the sociopathic boy, now an old man, has no other choice but to spend his final days sitting on her stump. And this makes her happy.

I like a lot of SS's other books, but this one, not so much.

horizontal rule
31

The tree doesn't try to guilt trip the boy

Yeah right. Just gives and gives, not trying to make him feel guilty at all. Fuckin passive aggressive tree.

horizontal rule
32

(I got issues with trees.)

horizontal rule
33

Be nice to mimes.

horizontal rule
34

As much as I dislike The Giving Tree, I don't hate it nearly as much as that fucking Little Prince.

horizontal rule
35

Be nice to mimes.

As long as they are not trying to interpret "The Giving Tree"


A-and hey! No hating on St.-Exupery!

horizontal rule
36

by the way, all this uncertainty about the right interpretation (is it environmentalism? is it God?)--drop that stuff.

SS made it clear with just one word: her.

That immediately made it an issue in gender politics. And that's what he intended: a depiction of das ewige Weibliche in all of its self-sacrificing, masochistic glory.

Sick fuck.

And, yeah, I haven't forgiven Lewis for his treatment of Susan, either. It's a legacy from Lewis Carroll, really: male British authors of childrens fiction are okay with girls, sorta, as long as they're *really* pre-pubescent.

And as long as they know their place. Then they're even allowed to be feisty now and then, for contrast. But not too much.

Even E. Nesbit, bless her heart, is more fair to her boys than her girls. Conversely, Arthur Ransome did pretty well by the Blackett girls. Pretty well for a male British author, anyhow.

horizontal rule
37

When I was a kid, I thought Susan was the lucky one. She didn't die in a freakin' train wreck!

horizontal rule
38

The story would have been a little different if instead of a train wreck, the children had been eaten by a lion in a zoo whom they had mistaken for Aslan and tried to get close to.

horizontal rule
39

Even E. Nesbit, bless her heart, is more fair to her boys than her girls.

"Bless her/his heart!" That's such a great Southern expression, mingling pity with contempt.

"Cousin Billy cussed at the judge and got thrown in jail. Bless his heart!"

horizontal rule
40

16: I hate that book. Every time I read it to Thing 1 and Thing 2, I made a mental note to be sure and instill in them a deep hatred of the Disney Corporation later on.

I always thought of The Giving Tree as an illustration of the Wallace Stevens line, "The world is ugly and the people are sad." You know, for kids.

The ultimate number one awful story? The Red Balloon. I saw that when I was nine or so, and I remember thinking "OH MY GOD! THEY JUST MURDERED HIS BEST FRIEND!" Just the thought of it fills me with dread.

horizontal rule
41

I liked the part in The Last Battle where the Muslim analogue gets into heaven. But pretty much everything else was just awful.

horizontal rule
42

What the hell, they die in a trainwreck? I've never read that book but I recently considered watching the movie when I was sick.

Also, did SS write that many country songs? I'm aware of two.

horizontal rule
43

Silverstein also wrote "Lord won't you buy me a Mercedes Benz", which makes up for a lot.

horizontal rule
44

No hating on St.-Exupery

Oh, I've got nothing but love for St.-Ex. He was cool. But for some reason The Little Prince really creeped me out when I was a kid. There was something ghostly about him. Maybe it was the baobab trees. I can't even remember now. But I still feel a slight thrill of disgust whenever I see the book.

horizontal rule
45

Man, threads like this make me feel unutterably white-bread and lame. All the books people are mentioning (except the Disney one about shapes and the Fox & Hound, both of which are previously unknown to me) are cherished childhood memories. I mean I had a pretty unhappy time of it as a kid but books like "The Red Balloon" and "The Little Prince" and Narnia were uplifting. But now I come to find out the Intelliwhatsitia despises them and by extension me.

horizontal rule
46

Every time I read it to Thing 1 and Thing 2

If you actually named your kids after Dr. Seuss characters, you'd be the most awesome person in history for like at least two minutes.

horizontal rule
47

stras--yeah, that was a slightly redeeming bit of universalism peeking out around the edges of Lewis' theology.

But not too much. Point being, it is easier for a worshiper of Baal to enter the kingdom of heaven than for a pubescent girl. Esp. one who actually *likes* lipstick.

Oh yeah, Red Balloon--horrible, black, depression. Screening that film for children is just pure child abuse.

horizontal rule
48

43: And the delightfully twisted "Uncle Shelby's ABZ Book."

horizontal rule
49

clown, dude, don't fret about it.

Fact is, if you have the emotional stability of a happy 40 year old and a psychic keel deeper than a racing yacht's, Red Balloon and all ain't going to rock you and shock you.

It's no hit on you to say that most infants are just a lot more susceptible than you were.

horizontal rule
50

But now I come to find out the Intelliwhatsitia despises them and by extension me.

And not just the Intelliwhatsitia. Thing 2 hates clowns, too.

horizontal rule
51

But not too much. Point being, it is easier for a worshiper of Baal to enter the kingdom of heaven than for a pubescent girl. Esp. one who actually *likes* lipstick.

Yeah, that's what gets me. The key to eternal life is following rigid, puritanical purity codes - and the good part is supposed to be that they're the same rigid, puritanical purity codes for every race, color and creed!

The ending was always the worst part, though, because it's supposed to be this joyously happy ending, but they're all dead and Narnia is destroyed and they'll never see Susan again. I mean, what the hell?

horizontal rule
52

Books that made me feel like shit, in chronological order:

Pale Green Pants With Nobody Inside Them
The Last Battle
The Great Gilly Hopkins

That last one takes the cake. I love it, but it really is kind of mindboggling that someone wrote a children's book about a girl who is at least partially to blame (to the extent that children can be to blame for anything) for her own desolation and loneliness. And there isn't any reprieve, or redemption, or suggestion that things might look up in a few years. The book just ends.

horizontal rule
53

Neil Gaiman's "The Problem of Susan", for those who are interested; I suspect the case of Susan is one of the major contributing factors in Pullman's decision to write "His Dark Materials".

42: Yeah, I was worried that was going to be a spoiler for someone, but I figured there was a 50-year exemption rule.

horizontal rule
54

Uncle Shelby's ABZ book renewed my faith in the human condition.

horizontal rule
55

I mean I had a pretty unhappy time of it as a kid but books like "The Red Balloon" and "The Little Prince" and Narnia were uplifting. But now I come to find out the Intelliwhatsitia despises them and by extension me.

I loved the Narnia books as a kid, but The Last Battle really, really used to depress me even then, and looking back there's a lot of screwed-up stuff in most of them.

What's wrong with The Red Balloon, other than that it's sad?

horizontal rule
56

And Clownae, how like shit I felt upon the train wreck in TLB is one of my cherished childhood memories.

horizontal rule
57

Pale Green Pants With Nobody Inside Them

But you were just as strange to them as they were strange to you!

horizontal rule
58

What's wrong with The Red Balloon, other than that it's sad?

Well, first there's the vicious murder of the title character, and then all the other balloons come and whisk Pascal away, which suggested to me that the world is a horrible, lonely, violent place where the best you can hope for is to go to heaven following some catastrophic, soul-rending sacrifice. But then, I was a sensitive kid.

horizontal rule
59

I suspect the case of Susan is one of the major contributing factors in Pullman's decision to write "His Dark Materials".

Yet another thing to hold against Lewis. (If he hadn't written the third book...)

horizontal rule
60

42: The two big hits were "Boy Named Sue" (Johny Cash, of course) and "One's On the Way" (Loretta Lynn).

Silverstein also wrote "25 Minutes to Go," which is about a hanging, also recorded by Johnny Cash. And "Boa Constrictor," which is a country song only because it was recorded by Cash.

horizontal rule
61

I agree with Kid Bitzer that The Giving Tree is about gender politics--it has to be, even if it wasn't intended as such, because self sacrifice is so gendered a concept.

I'm not sure that TGT is making a misogynist statement, though, because it is not clear to me that Silverstein is endorsing anyone's behavior here. He is depicting a relationship where one person only gives, and the other person only takes. We know such relationships exist. If Silverstein is saying anything about this relationship, he is saying something negative about it, because he makes you feel so sad for the tree.

When I read it to my kids, I use it as a negative example. You mother is like this tree; don't be like the boy.

horizontal rule
62

Trees aren't all bad. It was a tree that killed Sonny Bono.

horizontal rule
63

58: Is there no value in children's stories that show the world as a horrible, lonely, violent place, but one in which hope still exists? I don't think the movie is presenting that hope in as explicitly Christian a package as you seem to think, either: the balloon doesn't die to atone or save the boy; the boy is rewarded for his kindness with the kindness of others (in this case, the kindness of a bunch of other magical balloons).

horizontal rule
64

the trees got a Kennedy, too.

Red Balloon--basically it's Lord of the Flies in French. Maybe that's useful--it's good to learn early on that if you put a lot of boys in a pack, they all turn into Hutus.

You know, Bush is always driveling on about these universal human values. And he's right about that stuff. It's good to learn early on that, no matter what their accent is, no matter whether they are French villagers, British public school boys, or AIDS-infested Africans, if you put boys in a pack, they will seek out and destroy objects of beauty and of value.

And JMcQ is right that the Red Balloon is made much worse by the salvation at the end. It's enough to make a confirmed Nietzschean out of anyone--the afterlife as slim, implausible consolation for powerless and abuse at the hands of toddlers without conscience.

(Toddlers Without Conscience actually sounds like a good match for Doctors Without Borders. In a way.)

horizontal rule
65

You know what isn't nearly as fun as you think it will be?
Reading to kids. Videos rule.

horizontal rule
66

It's enough to make a confirmed Nietzschean out of anyone

And yet somehow the set of confirmed Nietzscheans remains smaller than the set of people who watched The Red Balloon as children.

horizontal rule
67

yeah, okay, you've got to read a bit of Nietzsche to get full membership rights, and that's kind of a bar for a lot of kindergartners.

I was actually a baptised Nietzschean, but I screwed up too much during the classes preparing for confirmation, so they wouldn't let me get confirmed.

Now I'm pretty much lapsed, you know, just sort of a social thing, community, do it for the kids and all.

horizontal rule
68

I think I mentioned on a previous thread that I remembered about three things from the Narnia books: the bit in Dawn Treader where Lucy casts the magic spell and hears her friends being mean to her, the bit (in Horse and His Boy?) where Aslan claws the princess across her back to mimc the whipping that the slave got because she escaped, and how much I hated the ending, both on "They're all dead!" and "Susan got totally screwed over" grounds.

Is it spoiling to reveal an awful ending? I kind of wish someone had told me the ending of His Dark Materials so I could not have bothered with the last book.

horizontal rule
69

they will seek out and destroy objects of beauty and of value

Or, failing that, humiliate you on Craigslist.

horizontal rule
70

You know what book I don't get? Green Eggs and Ham. I wouldn't eat those eggs either, they're fucking green! What the hell has to happen to an egg before it turns green? And how did that spread to the ham? And what kind of sociopath keeps pushing obviously diseased food on your after you have turned it down a billion times?

No, I won't eat them on a train! The goddamn train doesn't change the fact that those eggs are fucking green, and there's no fucking way I'm going to eat a goddamn green egg. What, are you trying to give me botulism or e-coli or something.

horizontal rule
71

You know what isn't nearly as fun as you think it will be? Reading to kids. Videos rule.

I disagree really really strongly with this assertion.

horizontal rule
72

surely the message is the anti-environmentalist one that trees, fundamentally, don't mind being cut down? (and that presumably and plausibly their brain and ability to feel pain is in the root-system, meaning that the above-ground part of the tree is equivalent to hair or fingernails).

horizontal rule
73

You know what book I don't get? Green Eggs and Ham. I wouldn't eat those eggs either, they're fucking green!

Nazi.

horizontal rule
74

surely the message is the anti-environmentalist one that trees, fundamentally, don't mind being cut down?

The only children who have ever cheered the boy in The Giving Tree have gone on to join the Cato Institute.

horizontal rule
75

71:

Would you like to come over and read to my children for five or six hours? Because, you know, they are totally up for being read to for that long. I honestly can't read to them for more than a half hour at a stretch before I just get too sleepy.

But if you are up for reading, we can always use more readers.

horizontal rule
76

Don't get me wrong, sj, I'm all for darkness in children's books/films, but I got no sense of hope from The Red Balloon. I mean, his best fucking friend. And then all the other balloons are like, the world sucks, let's get you out of here.

I love reading to my kids, which is a good thing, considering that it's just about the only reading I get to do these days.

horizontal rule
77

Oh, and Toddlers Without Conscience could kick Doctors Without Borders' ass.

horizontal rule
78

75: Totally man, I'd love to come up to the North Country and reading to your kids would be the perfect excuse. (For some values of "perfec".) Time alas does not permit such a journey right now.

horizontal rule
79

The rough part about reading to Caroline is that if you stop reading for just a second--for instance because it is four AM, and she woke you up and demanded you read to her and you just fell asleep again--she starts poking you and yelling "Wead! Wead!"

Her R's still sound like W's, and she still prefers one word commands, despite all our lessons about politeness, so all I ever hear is "Wead! Wead!"

I get the damn phrase in my head. If there is something I need to read for work, I start to hear an irate three year old saying “Wead! Wead!”

WEAD! WEAD!

horizontal rule
80

I didn't like Dr. Seuss books as a kid because I thought the illustrations were so horrendously ugly (but I did like The Lorax).

We had The Red Balloon and I loved it because of the photographs. I read it a million times yet I have no memory of it at all (except for the part when he meets a little girl on the street who's wearing all white and carrying a blue balloon). I don't remember being depressed by it whatsoever.

horizontal rule
81

Clownae, you may not understand that his kids want you to read the same fucking book over and over again for 2-3 hours. Kids love traditions.

horizontal rule
82

The Red Balloon photographs are as da says, a treasure. I also think this about the photographs in Jonathan Livingston Seagull, another Cherished Childhood Memory for which you all despise me.

horizontal rule
83

Emerson, I'm pretty well acquainted with the reading-to-kids routine.

horizontal rule
84

80: My daughters didn't get depressed by it either, apparently. We had some tired old balloons lying around a couple of days after a party, and the girls would proclaim "I'm the mean boy" and stomp on them.

horizontal rule
85

84 -- Did you read her Lord of the Flies yet?

horizontal rule
86

(Or Animal Farm

horizontal rule
87

)

horizontal rule
88

85: Funny you should ask. This is from my dormant blog; look at the photo and scroll down to the last paragraph.

horizontal rule
89

Speaking as we were of St-Exupery

horizontal rule
90

And, 88: cool. Just keep an eye on her around her smaller, weaker friends.

horizontal rule
91

green eggs and ham--

I actually like that one a fair bit.

But here too (as with giving tree), you just can't pretend not to know what that book is about. It's about deviant sex.

Could you, would you, in a boat? Could you, would you, with a goat?

Could anyone, would anyone, spell it out more plainly?

It's the attraction/repulsion of sexual tittilation.

Now myself, I'm not much into goats, boats, foxes, or boxes. But I did like the book.

Not so for the Cat in the Hat, which is all about the violation of the purity-taboo, esp. being smeared with feces. Not a nice book.

horizontal rule
92

91 wins.

horizontal rule
93

dare I ask, "what?"?

(note that both '?'s are required)

horizontal rule
94

Any contest it gets entered into.

horizontal rule
95

I imagine all of you, as children, dressed in gray flannel suits on the playground and scowling about mortgage rates.

horizontal rule
96

95 might win if it were not so fucking hostile.

horizontal rule
97

Now myself, I'm not much into goats, boats, foxes, or boxes

You do not like it, so you say --
Try it, try it, and you may!
Try it and you may, I say!

horizontal rule
98

(The above lifted from "To his Reluctant Mistress")

horizontal rule
99

nope. now 98 wins.

who knew that Dr. Suess stole his prosodic instincts from Andrew Marvell?

Had we but world enough and shoes on our feet
we could do with all of the creatures that bleat!

horizontal rule
100

Kobe!

horizontal rule
101

I don't think you're allowed to substitute "Kobe!" for "100!" when it's not basketball season, Clownae. It's like wearing white after labor day, or something.

horizontal rule
102

95 might win if it were not so fucking hostile.

I would contend that my comment was not, in fact, hostile, but I fear that any attempt to do so would only be perceived as hostile.

horizontal rule
103

Green Eggs and Ham was the book that I demanded my parents read to me over and over and over.

horizontal rule
104

Total weirdness -- 103 came through on the RSS feed with a malformed link to the holder of Guiness Record for bug-eyed staring; no such malformed link is included in the comment on unfogged.com though.

horizontal rule
105

Yeah, and when we did so, he would scream out, after each line, gleefully, "and green BACON!!!!". Totally threw off the rhyme scheme.

horizontal rule
106

Will you eat it in Macon?

horizontal rule
107

Isn't Green Eggs and Ham composed solely of 1-syllable words? So "bacon" would not fit that way either.

horizontal rule
108

(Or rather "1-syllable words + "anywhere"".)

horizontal rule
109

104: That was due to an errant paste command on my part that I went in and fixed.

horizontal rule
110

My favorite Dr. Seuss book was On Beyond Zebra.

horizontal rule
111

Giving Tree and Narnia both suck. OTOH, the Red Balloon (which I knew first as a movie) always made me terribly sad, but in a good way. It just seemed to me that yes, these things happen, and that's a true but awful thing about the world.

horizontal rule
112

Then there's this Silverstein song...

I never read The Giving Tree to my kid. I just read it online. Not exactly my idea of a good relationship. I mean, hell, would the offer of a little watering and some fertiliser have been beyond the reach of the boy/ man?? Tree exploiter!

My son's favourite you've-only-read-it-20-times book was King Bidgood's in the Bathtub.

What I got out of the Narnia novels: There's a scene where one of the Calormene soldiers does A Good Thing. Aslan says something on the lines of 'when you do good, it's always in my name, when you do evil, it's always in Tash's name, no matter what you say it is.' I think that solidified my secular philosophy [all religion is bunk], which had been pretty much got to the gel state after living in the Middle East. There's nothing like seeing the results of a religious war to make one into a five-year-old cynic, especially when one still bears the scar from the flying debris of a grenade attack.

horizontal rule
113

My son's favourite you've-only-read-it-20-times book was King Bidgood's in the Bathtub.

I loved that book when I was a kid.

horizontal rule
114

You know what has a fucking awful ending? The Dark is Rising series. I loved those, and felt absolutely betrayed by the end of the final book.

horizontal rule
115

As long as everyone agrees that "Where the Wild Things Are" is objectively the best children's book ever, I don't think we'll have any problems.

horizontal rule
116

MOOMINVALLEY IN NOVEMBER

(Actually, WTWTA is probably a superior child's book, while Moominvalley in November is just the greatest book that happens to be a child's book.)

horizontal rule
117

AND that fact that it's soon going to be an animated movie is likely terrible, terrible news. I love that book too much to see its characters splashed on the sides of Burger King kid's meals.

horizontal rule
118

Fuck Narnia. Fuck Narnia and feed Narnia fishheads.

I was never able to make myself read the series. I'd read Tolkien by the time I was 9 or 10, and Narnia was so obviously half assed that I'd always quit in disgust.

Writers who have potential but decide to ignore shit like plot and consistency within their created worlds just to beat us to death with their message need a beating. (Terry Goodkind, I'm looking at you.)

horizontal rule
119

115: No, The Phantom Tollbooth is objectively the best children's book ever.

horizontal rule
120

(I actually really enjoyed the Narnia books as a child and am rather sentimentally attached to them. But not in a way that involves my wanting to argue that all of you are wrong about them.)

You know what's really good? The Chronicles of Prydain. Loved those as a kid.

horizontal rule
121

Zadfrack has a point.

horizontal rule
122

I really didn't intend to inspire so much hatin' on Narnia. I loved the books, except for The Last Battle.

J. K. Rowling better not pull any bullshit with the final Harry Potter book, that's all I'm sayin'.

horizontal rule
123

Everyone goes to heaven except Hermione is what I heard.

horizontal rule
124

123: Yeah, the little tramp was starting wear lipstick and nylons, I hear.

horizontal rule
125

You people are so confused. Jacob Have I Loved is objectively the best children's book ever, though The Bronze Bow competes. It's all about the naturalism.

horizontal rule
126

First, Phantom Tollbooth is a "young reader" book, not a children's book (for ages 8-12ish vs. under 5). They're totally different animals. That being said, Amazon.com reviewers (the most objective possible measure) have given WTWTA a pure 5-stars, while TPT comes in with a mediocre 4.5.

Also, to my knowledge I've never read TPT.

horizontal rule
127

You know what children's (not young reader) book was great? Sheep in a Jeep.

horizontal rule
128

Oh, well if you're going to draw those kinds of distinctions. I think of all the books I read as a child, unless they were grownup books, as children's books.

horizontal rule
129

126: maybe you should remedy that.

horizontal rule
130

I once read The Ship's Cat to my first-grade class. The teacher was mighty embarrassed when I got to the part about "Jesuitical knavery," but I doubt any of the kids understood what was going on (least of all me).

horizontal rule
131

You people are on crack. The greatest children's book ever is The Gashlycrumb Tinies.

horizontal rule
132

128- Well, it is objectively better anyway, as the amazon reviews testify. [The same reviewers who collectively voted Ayn Rand the greatest author in history, I might add. Can their authoritative wisdom be contested?] But the only distinction I'm thinking of is between books that a child would typically read vs. have read to them. TPT looks like it a has a lot of words, in contrast to TGT or WTWTA. That's a meaningful difference, right? I'm not trying to create any very fine distinctions.

129- maybe. I don't know. I've never heard of it before now.

horizontal rule
133

I loved the Prydain books too as a kid. I'm kind of afraid to go back and read them now in case they actually suck.

horizontal rule
134

I wish I still had my Gashlycrumb Tinies poster.

horizontal rule
135

I was also profoundly affected by Pinkwater's Young Adult Novel.

horizontal rule
136

My wife bought me a copy of Green Eggs and Ham in Latin for Christmas last year.

Quovis loco tuam pernam,
Semper ova tua spernam.
Non mi placent, O Picerna.
Virent ova! Viret perna!

horizontal rule
137

134: I hope you don't die of ennui, ben.

horizontal rule
138

119 et seq.: I've probably bragged about this before, but I (and several other people) painted an 8'x10' mural of the Phantom Tollbooth map on a staircase wall at my MIT coop.

horizontal rule
139

132 - No, no. The Phantom Tollbooth is a fun read. I keep a copy at work.

The Prydain books hold up to adult reading. I went back to them a year ago; simple plot, but the books are what you remember.

I was mesmerized by Jacob Have I Loved, but think it is pretty messed up. I re-read that recently too and was even more disturbed. I wouldn't even nominate it for best children's book ever.

horizontal rule
140

Why is it messed up?

horizontal rule
141

Agreed, both the Prydain books and the Phantom Tollbooth hold up just fine. As does Young Adult Novel, for that matter.

I'm right there with LB on the Narnia books, both in terms of nostalgic fondness, and not feeling any need to defend them. What I really, REALLY don't want to try to defend, though, is my weird attachment to Lewis' profoundly problematic Out of the Silent Planet trilogy.

horizontal rule
142

This is me standing right here next to you also failing to defend them. Weird, aren't they? But fun.

horizontal rule
143

I never read Jacob Have I Loved, but Bridge to Terebithia, by the same author, is one depressing kid's book.

But not in a bad way, like The Last Battle.

horizontal rule
144

*Spoilers for Jacob Have I Loved, which you shouldn't read anyway.*
This is from memory, so I'll believe you if you tell me I have details wrong. But I was really creeped out by her attraction to the older-captain-guy and how they spent all that time together. And there was the constant comparison to her more beautiful twin, which I'm sorta remembering that the captain also participated in. The whole book was all dismal and grey and then she ended up living some compromise life, right?

You know, though, I am the wrong audience for naturalism. I like when underdogs overcome adversity and then it all turns out for the best despite difficulties.

***
I loved the Narnia books, and was disappointed when I re-read them. I can't defend them to grown-ups, but would still give them to any kid.

horizontal rule
145

Bridge to Terebithia

Also soon coming to a theatre near you.

I never read the Narnia books as a kid, though knew the story of TLTWATW from a cartoon version. (Come to think of it, to my recollection I never really read anything as a kid, other than as-assigned for school. Sad.) That's the only one I'm familiar with to this day. I've heard very mixed things about them and don't know whether or not I should get them for my kid.

horizontal rule
146

LB -- I mentioned to my friend Ed a little while back that the young'un and I are reading The Book of Three, and he said "Oh with Taran Wanderer? Those books totally fucked me up as a child, it took years to recover." His complaint was that they made it seem like everything you ever do or be in life was fated to happen, that you had to fulfil a particular destiny. (Also his upbringing was Mormon, I don't know if that plays into it.)

horizontal rule
147

131, 134: Hey wait! How did I forget about my Gashlycrumb Tinies poster? Where is it? I was the one who ate lye by mistake.

I still have my Nutshell Library from when I was a kid, and now my daughters love it, especially Pierre. Of course, books about how not to behave teach toddlers exactly those behaviors they're trying to discourage, so the girls like to sit backwards in their chairs and pretend to pour syrup in their hair.

horizontal rule
148

The Oz books are the best children's books ever.

horizontal rule
149

135: Well, it is a dada story. (Note my URL, yo!)

146: Naah. The whole point of the series, really, is that our preconceived notions of how we want things to to turn out is usually wrong, and the sign of being an adult is the ability to make the best of things and deal with what comes. They're great books for an eight year old (particularly a boy, as the girl-lessons happen entirely offstage), and I think it really got its roots into me in a way that the ethical brainwashing of Narnia didn't.

horizontal rule
150

the Oz books

Isn't there technically speaking one of those which is among the best evar and then a bunch which are kinda lame? I guess on average the whole series is vera vera good but still.

horizontal rule
151

149: Noted. I myself have thought than any soloblogging I might engage in in the future would be at a blog named Lizard Music.

horizontal rule
152

Lewis' profoundly problematic Out of the Silent Planet trilogy.

I loved those books, but the last time I read them I was 12 so I'm not really up on the subtext.

horizontal rule
153

150: Personally, I loved them all. They're like one big book to me.

horizontal rule
154

I believe the third one (That Hideous Strength?) features a female English graduate student writing on Donne (ha ha, we Oxford dons snicker, as we know only uncreative dilettantes write on Donne!), but by the end of the book, she's realized that that's going against nature for her to think and so resigns herself happily to being female.

Lewis is a twit, but more importantly, his writing suffers from needing to beat the reader over the head with analogies and jolly-good-fellowship. His idea of an exciting adventure is being stuck in Narnia -- without sandwiches!

horizontal rule
155

Lloyd Alexander's Prydain holds up entirely well to adult readers. I wouldn't hesitate to recommend it to young readers. The Phantom Tollbooth is objectively perfect, as well.

I refuse to all my early memories of adoring Narnia to be soiled by your... legitimate criticisms. *despair*

horizontal rule
156

The gender politics all through That Hideous Strength are the big problem, yes. Jane's trajectory -- which is quite compellingly, even brilliantly written -- is to learn how to be a good, obedient wife and to stop pretending to be an academic and face the fact that really she likes buying hats and being obedient. Plus incidentally at the end you learn that she and Mark spoiled one of mankind's best hopes for happiness and peace by using birth control. The worst and best thing about it is that her path to salvation through good obedient wifedom is rendered both seductive and surprisingly interesting. The book's idea of what women ought to be is dreadful, but the way that it treats the domestic and traditional female spheres with real attention and seriousness is actually, weirdly... well, I sure don't actually want to say feminist, but strangely laudable.

Oh, and there's an amazingly awful sadistic lesbian fascist cop lady.

horizontal rule
157

Oops, I guess I was sort of defending it there. But I want to be clear: the fact that I like a book that is all about (or, at least, half about) getting over your silly idea that you should think and resigning yourself to being female makes me feel very creepy.

horizontal rule
158

Oh, I'd forgotten about the birth control screed.

It is an elevation of the traditional feminine roles; it's clear that it valued them. Placing them on a pedestal, even, but it's a pedestal inside a comfy gilded cage.

horizontal rule
159

That Hideous Strength also features non-representational art being used as a Satanic recruiting tool.

horizontal rule
160

Another vote here for Pinkwater. Young Adult Novel, already mentioned, but also Alan Mendelsohn, the Boy from Mars, Slaves of Spiegel, and The Snarkout Boys and the Avocado of Death.

My kids love them and talk about them a lot, even after a few years have passed. I think my son has re-read them several times, and can regale you with what goes on and how things are described.

horizontal rule
161

Well, I think one of the things that's interesting there is that the Pilgrim's Progresses of Mark and Jane alike are told as Big Stories that hinge on very mundane details and small choices. I think that's admirable, because it represents a real adherence to the theological points Lewis cares about, instead of throwing it over in favor of rah-rah jolly good times with shiny swordplay. I think it's good writing, too, in that it makes those mundanities compelling. And I think that the elevation of the domestic there isn't quite on a pedestal in a comfy, gilded cage -- for one thing, nothing in That Hideous Strength is nearly as comfy as in any of the Narnia books (even allowing for the latter's being written for children), and for another, a lot of it seems to come from a place of greater real knowledge and appreciation of domestic detail. Wasn't THS written after Lewis' marriage?

So I think in any number of ways, it's his finest writing, but that that makes it that much more of a bummer that it boils down to something so unfortunate. (Now I'm thinking of how Camilla Denniston isn't allowed to go out to the dangerous wood in search of Merlin because Britain needs her womb. I mean, REALLY.)

horizontal rule
162

Oh god, yes, the evil Surrealism.

horizontal rule
163

The Oz book I identified with was The Marvelous Land of Oz where Tip, a boy, is discovered to be Ozma, the ensorcelled princess of Oz. She resents having to give up boy stuff for fancy dresses and girly things. I empathised completely. On the other hand, I thought General Jinjur's army was silly.

Dianna Wynne Jones has written a whole lot of great books; the Kid liked Charmed Life best. He's had an odd exposure to kids' books, as I did my master's thesis on British children's fantasy. He kept confusing "Psamead" with "Sam I Am".

horizontal rule
164

Young Adult Novel, already mentioned, but also Alan Mendelsohn, the Boy from Mars, Slaves of Spiegel, and The Snarkout Boys and the Avocado of Death.

<ronco>Conveniently collected in a single volume, Five Novels. Operators are standing by!</ronco>

Ms Wynne Jones is fabulous. Shame about what Miyazaki took away from Howl's Moving Castle, as I would have thought that he would have enjoyed the spunky feminism and not turned it into a formulaic anti-war tract.

horizontal rule
165

*********SPOILERS***********

This is from memory, so I'll believe you if you tell me I have details wrong. But I was really creeped out by her attraction to the older-captain-guy and how they spent all that time together. And there was the constant comparison to her more beautiful twin, which I'm sorta remembering that the captain also participated in. The whole book was all dismal and grey and then she ended up living some compromise life, right?

You know, though, I am the wrong audience for naturalism. I like when underdogs overcome adversity and then it all turns out for the best despite difficulties.

I went back and reviewed some plot details by perusing the Amazon reviews. Her crush on the captain is certainly weird, but it's not like it's either consummated or God forbid consummated and then celebrated for being so. I think teenage girls and boys, and people in general, develop weird passions for bizarre objects, and it's great to write about that in a sympathetic way for children. It was especially understandable given her situation; she was so totally socially isolated precisely at the time she was having a sexual awakening that it kind of makes sense that she would fixate on the one person who was giving her a sense of power and freedom by introducing her to her own ablities as a fisherwoman.

And yeah, the whole point of the book is that she's in the shadow of her beautiful twin, and it's extremely unpleasant and constricting for her, but she doesn't lead a compromised life at the end--she becomes a doctor or a nurse depending on which Amazon review you read, and in the end delivers twin babies, sees that one of them is weaker and more frail, and is forced to care for the weaker while she puts the stronger one aside, and she realizes for the first time what other people have told her--that some, though not all, of what she experienced as abandomnent was actually a recognition that she was strong. I think, not having the book in front of me, that you could make a case that this is kind of fucked--I mean, who is strong and who is weak really, Louise certainly felt lonely enough and her family could have spared the resources for both children, if not in money, in love, and also it's slightly conveniently cliched that the pretty girl who was the good singer was also physically ill--it's an easy amalgamation of femminess and debility to sort of get around the question of just why it is Caroline is so weak so it's not just blond hair that makes her so, but on the other hand the book, as I remember, that Louise wasn't seriously wronged in some ways, just that she might not have understood what Caroline suffered at all times, and the main point is that what can look to you like ease and favor isn't necessarily, and you can fail to know someone as close to you even as your own twin sister. And the very end of the book (as I recall) is her hearing the sound of her sister singing as she walks through the night and being able to recognize it as beautiful for the first time. It's really a book about overcoming solipsism.
*************END SPOILERS**********************

I do rather like naturalism, especially for children. I always liked my characters suffering, and not in a way that any pterodactyl would rescue them from, even when I was nine. Everyone should read Jacob Have I Loved

horizontal rule
166

That Hideous Strength also features non-representational art being used as a Satanic recruiting tool.

Which is perfectly in keeping with the book's premise that modernism itself is a vast demonic conspiracy. It may be better-written and more entertaining than most of the books in the Christian paranoia genre (see for example This Present Darkness, where public school officials are possessed by demons who fiendishly conspire to indoctrinate children in the dark arts of evolutionary theory, sex education, and transcendental meditation), but it's still wildly overwrought and shlocky in a way that makes it impossible for me to appreciate.

Most of the Narnia stuff, at least, still works pretty well as children's fantasy, even under the layers of religious symbolism. The grossly conservative gender politics is harder to get around, obviously. I probably can't rationally justify my continued fondness for Narnia, and even one of my favorite scenes from my favorite one (Puddleglum fighting the Emerald Queen's hypnosis) turns out to be a thinly-veiled screed against materialism in retrospect. But there you have it.

horizontal rule
167

Pinkwater! Lizard Music might be one of my favorite books in the universe. I was Pinkwater-deprived as a child, and only introduced to him relatively late in life by a Pinkwater-loving friend, but I've decided to make up for this by feeding them to my young nieces and nephews.

His picture books are pretty amazing, too.

horizontal rule
168

Toothgnasher Superflash and Doodle Flute are special favorites here.

horizontal rule
169

165 - Don't read it! There's no pterodactyl to save everyone in the end! There isn't a contest that they win by banding together, so that all their strengths contribute and they learn to appreciate each other FOR their differences! Things just happen and then they just adapt. Sometimes, it is ambiguous! Or sad! Don't read it! There's no point!

horizontal rule
170

I love C.S. Lewis, but I have to admit that Cala's comment in 154 ("His idea of an exciting adventure is being stuck in Narnia -- without sandwiches!") is devastating.

horizontal rule
171

Freaky kids book to make toddlers weep: Nintje/Miffy, Dutch antecedent to Hello Kitty. In which Mr. & Mrs. Rabbit enjoy gardening and shopping respectively (ugh), but are sadly childless. Until an angel (!) appears and tells them that that Nintje will arrive. Then the animals show up. But cows and chickens can't play with newborn Christ-analogues, so they have to leave. And the family goes to bed. And my child cries, and begs us to read it again.

Had to hide that motherfucker.

79: Wow, I hadn't appreciated how nice "Pease read the book pease" is until I heard the alternative.

horizontal rule
172

As always, commenting last on a dead thread... but still, try Jacob Two-Two and the Hooded Fang out on your kids. It's like a young child's precursor to Lemony Snicket's Series of Unfortunate Events.

horizontal rule
173

commenting last

Says you.

horizontal rule
174

If you kids don't stop bickering I am going to turn this thread right around and head home, do you hear me?

horizontal rule
175

count me among the deeply conflicted narnia-lovers.
Would we like them so much if they hadn't got to us early? Is it just that they were our first exposure to the genre?

But, yeah, rereading doesn't flatter them.

Hey, among my favorite picture-books is a series by Tim Wynne-Jones: Zoom, Zoom Away, and Zoom Upstream. About a talking cat and his hubba-hubba friend Maria. Gorgeous drawings, and some of the most beautifully laconic, lapidary dialogue this side of Mamet. (not so many f-words, luckily).

Anyone know if Tim is related to Dianne W-J?

Oh, and can't forget Maira Kalman. 'Max in Love' is pure genius.

horizontal rule
176

Pinkwater... I was given The Snarkout Boys and the Avocado of Death when I was a kid, and tried to read it as a pulp adventure fiction, which left me turned off of Pinkwater for a good long while. Didn't really get him until I read the five novels collection when I was 25. Over and over again. I probably would have reacted better to Young Adult Novel, which didn't have any of the slightly confusing trappings of science fiction.

Lewis: Till We Have Faces (his retelling of the Psyche myth) is a very good book. Never read the Space Trilogy.

horizontal rule
177

I made myself quite unpopular with the teachers in Oklahoma when they were encouraging us to read those Prydain books, because I had been taught the Mabinogion (the series of Welsh folk tales that they are ripped off from) in school in Wales the previous year and could not be stopped from explaining what a travesty they were. I have no idea of their merits as books but it really was quite irritating to my ten-year-old Nashie self. It didn't help that my main complaint about the books is that they tended to leave out the massacres and rapes in the original.

horizontal rule
178

171: One of the Dutch Nijntje/Miffy books has her grandmother dying, complete with dead body. You can tell she's dead because her eyes are little Xs. In the end Nijntje is happy because she gets to put flowers on the grave.

horizontal rule
179

I love the narnia books despite everything. I remember once when I was 7 and had already read the lion the witch and the wardrobe a million times I decided to see how quickly I could read it if I went as fast as possible...30 minutes! I think it might take me longer now. the prydain books (that's the black cauldron etc., right?) are more problematic than you remember princess eilonwy is actually an extraordinarily passive figure. I too find the lewis trilogy strangely appealing. really, though, for depressing kids stories HC anderson wins the prize. it's one of the cornerstones in my hatred of disney that they turned the little mermaid into some bullshit razzle dazzle with cheerful negro crabs. where's the part with how it's like walking on knife blades?

horizontal rule
180

cala's comment on the missing sandwiches in narnia is devastating indeed--very good snark

It wins her a +15 snark-mistress, and means she will prevail in any contest with an opponent armed only with High Church Anglican Earnestness, provided they have an HCAE rating of less than +30. (Luckily no one has ever received a rating over +10. and yes I know he was a papist, but the mind-rays are pure anglican.)

But here's the thing: the juxtaposition of alternate worlds and missing sandwiches--the fabulous and domestic--that was actually a brilliant invention when E. Nesbit first came up with it. (Did I mention she was the greatest children's author of all time?)

It's the way to make magic more magical, not less, more vivid, because you can see it happening to kids like you, right here in a life like your own life.

When the kids meet the psammead, their reaction modulates from wonder and astonishment very quickly into negotiating with a new, caricature adult--a very powerful, very vain grownup (and here's the crucial bit) who can be manipulated with ordinary methods available to kids, like wheedling and flattering.

If it was all fantastic strangeness and no missing sandwiches, there'd be no way for the kid to buy in. (How many kids thrill to the myths of William Blake? How did Pullman adopt them to try to get their buy in?)

Sure, it can be twee and cloying, but in Nesbit's hands it is genius. And yes, she is the greatest author of children's books of all time.

horizontal rule
181

I'm not denying that the juxtaposition of the fantastic and the mundane is a great way to draw children into literaure. I'm denying that Lewis it did it particularly well.

horizontal rule
182

spot on. jolly good. complete accord, expressions of respect.

horizontal rule
183

I also think it's much older than Nesbitt. Or at least there's then another reason that fairy tales generally introduce the Hero as the youngest son of the poor but honest woodcutter who defeats the evil goblins/witch queen/monster with pluck, hard work, and luck.

horizontal rule
184

I hated Narnia with a passion when I was a kid, because I felt it was dishonest in a way I couldn't put my finger on at the time, but in retrospect I think was down to a feeling that the whole scenarion failed as an allegory of the Christian story, so that it didn't work for me either as an adventure (too contrived) or as religious propaganda.

I entirely endorse the kid's plug for Nesbit, though.

horizontal rule
185

But here's the thing: the juxtaposition of alternate worlds and missing sandwiches--the fabulous and domestic--that was actually a brilliant invention when E. Nesbit first came up with it. (Did I mention she was the greatest children's author of all time?)

Oh, absolutely. Although it's a shame that her domesticity -- the groundedness in detail -- makes her somewhat less accessible to modern kids. I found The Story Of The Amulet in third grade or so, and loved it, but was completely lost and confused in the normal bits that happened in London. I think that was the right age to read the book if I'd had the background for it, but I had an easier time with the rest of her books that I didn't come across until I was older and knew a little more about the period.

horizontal rule
186

I think it might take me longer now. the prydain books (that's the black cauldron etc., right?) are more problematic than you remember princess eilonwy is actually an extraordinarily passive figure.

Yeah. She's described as powerful and independent, but gets very little time actually as the focus of the book. I still loved them, I just identified with Taran.

horizontal rule
187

185: I read all those books around age 10, and there were about 500 things that I had to ask my parents what were, and they knew about half of them (because my mom had read all 145,000 Wodehouse books and books about royal history). None of us were able to understand what was so funny about confusing the words "antiquary" and "antiquity", though.

horizontal rule
188

Further on the Question of Susan: Kung Fu Monkey gets email.

horizontal rule
189

I feel like it's not exactly that Eilonwy is passive, but that her vigor is almost all offstage, as per 149. Like hey, maybe there's some Shadow Chronicles of Prydain where we actually get to see all of her interesting development and ass-kicking. Maybe that's a distinction without a difference, though.

horizontal rule
190

We just got to meet Orddu, Orwen and Orgoch, and are big fans of the three.

horizontal rule
191

Says me, nyah nyah.

horizontal rule
192

Oh yeah?

horizontal rule
193

Parking lot. 3.

horizontal rule
194

I'll be there.

horizontal rule
195

Speaking of children's literature, much of Oxford around Exeter college has been surrounded by film crews the past few days. They're making the first film from the Pullman trilogy (Northern Lights/the Golden Whatever)..

horizontal rule
196

Nobody rang for you. We're in a last comment contest here, mate.

horizontal rule
197

"mate" s/b "etam".

horizontal rule
198

They're making the first film from the Pullman trilogy

Too bad it'll be live-action and effects. I'd hoped that by some miracle it would turn into a Miyazaki film.

horizontal rule
199

That Miyazaki "totally changing the ending" magic would also be welcome. (I've only seen Howl.)

horizontal rule
200

(I've only seen Spirited Away.)

horizontal rule
201

Kiki is strongly recommended by everybody at the Clownæ house. The young'un and I liked Spirited Away a lot, if not quite as much; Mrs. Clown&aelg; was not too enthusiastic about it.

horizontal rule
202

aelg!

horizontal rule
203

Didn't like Kiki at all. Howl's is pretty good. Spirited Away is great. Somehow I don't really remember Princess -- I think I feel asleep or something.

horizontal rule
204

We're in a last comment contest here, mate.

Ahem.

horizontal rule
205

And who has the only comment 1435 on this blog?

horizontal rule
206

Answer: Not you.

horizontal rule
207

Ain't over 'til it's over, Weiner.

horizontal rule
208

That's a good point, Weiner.

Posted by: Giant Mutant Cockroach | Link to this comment | 09-20-06 10:00 AM
_______________________________________________________

1435

208 makes a well thought out and persuasive argument.

Posted by: Cockroach Sprezzatura | Link to this comment | 09-20-06 10:02 AM
______________________________________________________

1436

I win!

horizontal rule
209

That thread is over.

horizontal rule
210

OK, the cockroaches win.

horizontal rule
211

And by some miracle I won it!

horizontal rule
212

For now.

horizontal rule
213

Say, what proportion of the posts in the "Innocence" thread were purely vieing for last-comment status? 20? 40? 85?

horizontal rule
214

It must kill Apo to have the power to win so readily within his grasp. He could easily just un-archive the innocence thread, leave a final, glorious comment, and then seal it back up forever. I assume only his magnanimity and greatness of soul have prevented him.

Also, I am in awe of the technical prowess that produced 1435 and 1436.

horizontal rule
215

That's "vying", bitch.

It must kill Apo to have the power to win so readily within his grasp. He could easily just un-archive the innocence thread, leave a final, glorious comment, and then seal it back up forever. I assume only his magnanimity and greatness of soul have prevented him.

Actually, he couldn't, for two reasons:

1. Un-archiving a thread is not as simple as you might think.
2. I put some perl in the MT code that checks to see if you're leaving a comment on Innocence, and if you are displays a snarky message saying that I've won.

horizontal rule
216

I play the long game, Brock.

horizontal rule
217

Wait, so what you're suggesting is that And by some miracle I won it! should be And by the grace of Wolfson I won it!?

That takes some of the joy out of my victory, I must say.

horizontal rule
218

218: really, JM, I won it, for while I did not leave the last comment, I am lord and master over the prospect of further last comments.

Indeed, before it was archived, the message that you got when you tried to leave a comment was "Sorry, wolfson won". And the text of your comment was changed to "I submit to wolfson's authority". And your name to "A humble peon".

horizontal rule
219

Because the referees hold the power of winning and losing in their grasp, do they thereby win the game? Nay.

horizontal rule
220

Matt, let Wolfson believe in his omnipotence. It's adorable.

horizontal rule
221

Good thing I wasn't around for a 3 o'clock beating - I had no idea what I was letting myself in for. I'm hoping the Ahem: Innocence link will provide some clue, but it's taking an awful long time to load. That's a bad sign. Ah, there it is... and an awful long thing it is too.

As to the Miyazaki films, there's not one that my kids don't thrill to. Highly recommended!

horizontal rule
222

BTW LB, on the subject of with whom to identify when reading of Prydain, throughout Book of 3 and Black Cauldron, my young daughter has been identifying with Gurgi -- I'm so proud...

On the subject of Kiki vs. Spirited, she says to tell you "I like both."

horizontal rule
223

My kids are split on those.

horizontal rule
224

identifying with Gurgi

You know who Gurgi is? Grover gone wild.

horizontal rule
225

224 -- totally -- the first thing she noticed about him is that like Elmo, he refers to himself in the third person. She decided Elmo and Gurgi should get married -- they are both boys but "they can have a boy family, and no girls allowed".

horizontal rule
226

(Actually that was the second thing -- first thing was that he talks in rhymes, also quite a Muppet-y attribute.)

horizontal rule
227

My parents didn't believe in Sesame Street. And it was one of the weaker children's television shows on when our kids were little, so they didn't watch much either. There's nothing missing in a life without Sesame Street.

horizontal rule
228

But maybe it's a little poorer without Jim Henson.

What *would* he have done given the advances in technology since his death?

horizontal rule
229

Maybe?!

horizontal rule
230

Maybe not maybe.

horizontal rule
231

Was (Not Was)

horizontal rule
232

Not only do I not get the meaning of 231, I do not know how to type the 'ae' in Clownaesthesiologist.

horizontal rule
233

&aelig;

horizontal rule
234

Was (Not Was)

horizontal rule
235

Btw, to make 233 type

&amp;aelig;
horizontal rule
236

But how do I type 235???

horizontal rule
237

I saw Was (Not Was) in concert, opening for the Neville Brothers. They were both awesome. I shall now go walk the dinosaur.

horizontal rule
238

236: type @#% without the shift key.

(Yes, I'm committing a use-mention error.)

horizontal rule
239

...and I'm off to shul.

Feel free to try for the last comment, heathens.

horizontal rule
240

Shanah tovah!

horizontal rule
241

Wrong thread, CÆ.

horizontal rule
242

What are you talking about? Weiner said he was going to shul so I wished him a happy new year. (Shouldn't you be in temple yerself?)

horizontal rule
243

Rosh Hashanah greetings belong in the escort thread. I mean, come on.

(Services ended hours ago in this time zone.)

horizontal rule
244

Oh right. Happy NY!

horizontal rule
245

(I am Becks-style on this holy night, and I am watching The Pink Panther.

horizontal rule
246

)

horizontal rule
247

)

horizontal rule
248

Woo-hoo! BTW Teo, I am curious to know whether my description of Mark Rubinfine's take on the Judaic experience as being like yours comes through in the bit I excerpt. -- Rereading my excerpt I am not so sure -- but in the context of the book the resemblance is striking.

horizontal rule
249

I think the resemblance is indeed striking even outside of its context.

horizontal rule
250

Oh -- that's good to know.

horizontal rule
251

I haven't read the book, so I don't know how the excerpt you quoted fits into the rest of the story, but it's definitely typical of a certain kind of attitude toward Judaism. I would need more information to know if it's precisely the same attitude I have (it probably isn't, actually).

horizontal rule
252

Well the first part is about 4 friends who have various relationships with Judaism, Alex-Li Tandem (main character of the book) is an atheist and neglectful of observance, Mark is a rabbi but does not believe strongly in God, Adam is a mystic and kabbalist, and Joseph is -- not sure, he's a bit of a cipher -- but he's definitely on Mark's side in terms of chiding Alex-Li to be more observant -- and he interacts with Adam in Adam's visionary mode -- but he seems to be an atheist. But I'm not sure about him, I'll need to reread it to get what's going on with him.

horizontal rule
253

Sounds like none of them are straightforward theists, then. Interesting.

horizontal rule
254

Ohh, contemporary R&B dance music, too bad.

So I just cut and paste: &aelig; Hm, the preview shows no so how about this: æ and voila!

Voila! I say.

horizontal rule
255

And a loaf of kosher vanilla halva for each of you.

horizontal rule
256

Mmm, halva...

horizontal rule
257

I'll halve a loaf of the halva loaf I have, if you'd prefer.

horizontal rule
258

Cause I have one too many loaves obviously.

horizontal rule
259

I'm having a hot toddy. It's delicious.

horizontal rule
260

I'm having rye whiskey with sesame seed paste: not really a natural combo, but tasty. And it seems to excite the blog-comment neurons.

horizontal rule
261

I suppose you're having them side by side, but damned if I wasn't contemplating the relative (de)merits of smeared around the rim vs. glob at the bottom.

horizontal rule
262

As you know, we evolved blog-commenting neurons in the early Pleistocene.

horizontal rule
263

Low-hanging:

smeared around the rim vs. glob at the bottom

ATM

horizontal rule
264

Back on the veldt, tendentious arguing was advantageous because it meant less time engaging in dangerous pursuits like hunting and fighting tigers.

horizontal rule
265

Or doing your coin-laundry.

horizontal rule
266

Autumn! [EDT]

horizontal rule
267

Actually I bet a sesame-flavored syrup in some rye could be worth trying.

horizontal rule
268

Does sesame syrup exist? Like in those shot-flavour bottles you can't help stare at while crappy chain coffeeshops pull your drink off the assembly line?

horizontal rule
269

I bet you could make some pretty easily, if it doesn't.

horizontal rule
270

The most relevant link I could find said something about "Tahin" in Turkish, which is "Tahini," which is Not It. So, I'd say no.

horizontal rule
271

Googling doesn't seem to shed much light on the issue; there are references to sesame oil but nothing that clearly indicates that it exists as a product.

horizontal rule
272

Oh, you can definitely get sesame oil. I've seen it.

horizontal rule
273

I bet you could make some pretty easily, if it doesn't.

That's what I've been doing all evening.

horizontal rule
274

This thread is pretty interesting, but doesn't have much to do with sesame syrup.

("oil" s/b "syrup" in 271. Sesame oil is of course easily available.)

horizontal rule
275

You know, ahab, it seems like every time I look at the recent comments sidebar there's a comment from you in this thread. What's up with that?

horizontal rule
276

It looks like most of the websites about sesame syrup are recipes for it, so yeah, you probably have to make it yourself.

horizontal rule
277

B-dub, I've learned how to make two good drinks from you, but I'm doubtful about this sesame oil concoction you're proposing.

horizontal rule
278

275: You're a sperm whale?

horizontal rule
279

Not oil, syrup. If I had some sesame seeds, and some rye, I'd give it a go right now! But I don't, so we'll never know.

horizontal rule
280

I just got 278. It's funny.

horizontal rule
281

I'm tellin' ya, it works. The halva and whiskey, that is.

horizontal rule
282

Jacob Two-Two and the Hooded Fang

Holy shit, just saw that comment. I have a true story involving Jacob Two-Two, Ebay, the police in Brooklyn, and a mysterious stranger.

But it's kinda boring, so I'll spare you.

horizontal rule
283

281: WE'LL NEVER KNOW.

horizontal rule
284

"so I'll spare you" s/b "so I'll tease you"

horizontal rule
285

I already gave away the best parts; just use your imagination.

horizontal rule
286

I was imagining you actually had a story to tell.

"Some tales sail; some tales sink, no less true": Beowulf and Grendel, the pretty alright movie I watched last night.

horizontal rule
287

278 was awesome, so I'll stop hassling you.

horizontal rule
288

Cool. But will you let me have the last post?

horizontal rule
289

Looking forward to another go-round this evening.

horizontal rule
290

The last post.

horizontal rule
291

288: only if you stop asking me questions.

horizontal rule
292

When can I ask questions again?

horizontal rule
293

When you don't mind me answering them.

horizontal rule
294

So, it being the 23rd, will comments be perma-archived tonight? At midnight? PST?

horizontal rule
295

Dude, I don't know.

horizontal rule
296

You've probably had enough of this, eh?

horizontal rule
297

Just about, just about.

horizontal rule
298

I certainly have.

horizontal rule