Re: Guest Post - Schism!

1

A guy I went to graduate school with, who pointed me in the direction of my first professional job, is now an Orthodox priest. Not sure what kind.


Posted by: Moby Hick | Link to this comment | 10-18-18 11:23 AM
horizontal rule
2

Anyway, it's nice that they consider this bigger than the entire Protestant Reformation.


Posted by: Moby Hick | Link to this comment | 10-18-18 11:35 AM
horizontal rule
3

Pikers, a bunch of Ivans-come-lately. The Armenian and Georgian Orthodox Churches are not only autocephalous but also apostolic.


Posted by: Doug | Link to this comment | 10-18-18 11:44 AM
horizontal rule
4

2: From the Orthodox perspective that was just a silly skirmish among the heathens.


Posted by: peep | Link to this comment | 10-18-18 11:53 AM
horizontal rule
5

I'm a little too drunk and this is a little too byzantine to follow.


Posted by: Barry Freed | Link to this comment | 10-18-18 11:54 AM
horizontal rule
6

The Ft of all people had a leader on this on Monday. I don't think it will get papered over. The orthodox reall do hate each other with astonishing venom, and can keep it up for centuries. Besides, there is a lot of church property in the Ukraine which will change hands as a result of this.


Posted by: NW | Link to this comment | 10-18-18 12:28 PM
horizontal rule
7

I remember when all the Russians were atheists. I guess it didn't stick.


Posted by: Spike | Link to this comment | 10-18-18 12:55 PM
horizontal rule
8

2: The Reformation was a whole lot of little schisms spread over decades. This one breaks the Orthodox church in half overnight.


Posted by: Mossy Character | Link to this comment | 10-18-18 2:38 PM
horizontal rule
9

I feel like I would need to look up statistics to dispute that and I don't want to learn. Still, I wonder if just the Martin Luther schism wasn't more central to the then-current Christan world than the Orthodox church of a country that uses to be atheist.


Posted by: Moby Hick | Link to this comment | 10-18-18 3:14 PM
horizontal rule
10

Wikipedia says Russia and Ukraine put together have over 60% of the global population of Eastern Orthodox adherents*, so this is pretty important.

* For each of those countries taking the midpoint of the lower and upper estimates found here. Adding Romania, Greece, Serbia, and Belarus gets me to over 80%. US is #19.


Posted by: Minivet | Link to this comment | 10-18-18 5:02 PM
horizontal rule
11

I'm not sure why we need to add in Romania et al. The Orthodox in one country (Russia) are splitting from the orthodox Orthodox. I don't see why that automatically counts as a bigger deal than a good chunk of the Holy Roman Empire becoming Protestant. For one thing, we know that the latter started a war that killed like a 3rd of Germany and we don't even know that the former will outlive Putin.


Posted by: Moby Hick | Link to this comment | 10-18-18 5:30 PM
horizontal rule
12

The Russians are being self-dramatizing assholes is what I'm proposing as a thesis.


Posted by: Moby Hick | Link to this comment | 10-18-18 5:39 PM
horizontal rule
13

Moby so gloomy. Schisms don't happen every day you know. Enjoy the show!


Posted by: Mossy Character | Link to this comment | 10-18-18 8:40 PM
horizontal rule
14

Substantively:
That one country breaking off has at least 30% of all Orthodox, which I'm pretty sure makes it proportionally the biggest single schism since 1054.
Politically, it matters because Putin has pan-Slavism as part of his propaganda system, and this break puts the lie to that pretty starkly.
Historically, granting autocephaly to Ukraine breaks a church hierarchy established during the Russian empire, and so marks another step in that empire's disintegration.
World-historically (stretching my knowledge badly), the 30 Years' War was only marginally about Protestantism. What it was largely about was the consolidation of state power, and it ended with the subordination of religious affairs to the state in most (all?) of the Empire. Assuming this schism sticks (and I'll take NW's judgment on that) the Russian church, stripped of universalist pretensions, will be left as what it has really been for a long time: an arm of the Russian state. That might be taken as a late echo of early modernism, or an omen of future Orwellianism, or (what I think) both.


Posted by: Mossy Character | Link to this comment | 10-18-18 9:19 PM
horizontal rule
15

Also worth noting is the fact that all of Russian Orthodoxy, indeed all Russia, began in Kiev. It's a psychological blow to lose it, or, perhaps, be lost to it.


Posted by: foolishmortal | Link to this comment | 10-18-18 9:59 PM
horizontal rule
16

What it was largely about was the consolidation of state power

I mean, so was protestantism, in many places at least.


Posted by: Ginger Yellow | Link to this comment | 10-18-18 11:07 PM
horizontal rule
17

Exactly. It's all about control, man.


Posted by: Mossy Character | Link to this comment | 10-18-18 11:16 PM
horizontal rule
18

||

The author's own great-great-great-grandfather, Maha Mindin Thinkaya, the Myoza of Dabessway, escaped assassination as he had stayed at home that day owing to a bad cold. Kanaung, though, was decapitated and his head was paraded about the nearby passage by Myinhkondaing.
|>


Posted by: Mossy Character | Link to this comment | 10-18-18 11:30 PM
horizontal rule
19

18 is a great aside, well up there with MRD Foot's "The bars of most Gestapo cells, though impressive in appearance, were generally held in place by a few thin strips of metal, which could easily be cut using a wire saw*."

And there's a footnote:
"Personal experience."


Posted by: ajay | Link to this comment | 10-19-18 1:18 AM
horizontal rule
20

What it was largely about was the consolidation of state power

true enough, that. I never believed a word of that Lutheran crap.


Posted by: Opinionated Henry VIII | Link to this comment | 10-19-18 2:13 AM
horizontal rule
21

6. I read a thing (possibly via you) where the author analysed a well known picture of "Lenin discussing with some peasants", and showed, with reference to their beard styles and dress code that what Lenin was actually doing was recruiting the Old Believers.


Posted by: chris y | Link to this comment | 10-19-18 2:18 AM
horizontal rule
22

a little too byzantine

I see what you did there.


Posted by: politicalfootball | Link to this comment | 10-19-18 5:40 AM
horizontal rule
23

(This is where my Harald Hardrada post should have gone but in reality his legend touches all timelines and belong on all threads.)


Posted by: tierce de lollardie | Link to this comment | 10-19-18 6:21 AM
horizontal rule
24

Once I saw this guy on a bridge about to jump. I said, "Don't do it!" He said, "Nobody loves me." I said, "God loves you. Do you believe in God?"

He said, "Yes." I said, "Are you a Christian or a Jew?" He said, "A Christian." I said, "Me, too! Protestant or Catholic?" He said, "Protestant." I said, "Me, too! What franchise?" He said, "Baptist." I said, "Me, too! Northern Baptist or Southern Baptist?" He said, "Northern Baptist." I said, "Me, too! Northern Conservative Baptist or Northern Liberal Baptist?"

He said, "Northern Conservative Baptist." I said, "Me, too! Northern Conservative Baptist Great Lakes Region, or Northern Conservative Baptist Eastern Region?" He said, "Northern Conservative Baptist Great Lakes Region." I said, "Me, too!"

Northern Conservative†Baptist Great Lakes Region Council of 1879, or Northern Conservative Baptist Great Lakes Region Council of 1912?" He said, "Northern Conservative Baptist Great Lakes Region Council of 1912." I said, "Die, heretic!" And I pushed him over.


Posted by: Emo Phillips | Link to this comment | 10-19-18 7:06 AM
horizontal rule
25

3 - the Armenians are even non-Chalcedonian. Don't know for sure about the Georgians.


Posted by: Tom Scudder | Link to this comment | 10-19-18 11:21 AM
horizontal rule
26

Mostly Baptist, I think.


Posted by: Moby Hick | Link to this comment | 10-19-18 11:23 AM
horizontal rule
27

24: Disturbing. First they came for the Region Council of 1912...


Posted by: bill | Link to this comment | 10-20-18 10:38 AM
horizontal rule
28

25: The Infallible Wikipedia tells me that the Georgian Orthodox Church waffled a bit, but eventually landed on the Chalcedonian side, the better to forge alliances with Constantinople against the Persians.


Posted by: Doug | Link to this comment | 10-21-18 7:56 AM
horizontal rule
29

That worked. They were never conquered by Persians.


Posted by: Moby Hick | Link to this comment | 10-21-18 8:00 AM
horizontal rule
30

26: The better to form alliances with Americans.


Posted by: Mossy Character | Link to this comment | 10-21-18 8:05 AM
horizontal rule
31

It really is Byzantine.


Posted by: Mossy Character | Link to this comment | 10-30-18 3:18 AM
horizontal rule
32

Don't believe the hype!

Epiphanius's enthronement was attended by only one high-ranking representative from a Local Church -- Metropolitan Emmanuel of Gaul, of the Patriarchate of Constantinople.


Posted by: Mossy Character | Link to this comment | 02-14-19 9:21 AM
horizontal rule